Successful Onside Kick Super Bowl Prop Bet Payout

How often do we see successful onside kicks?  Not often and the payout odds for this prop bet show that.  The payout is $1500 on a $100 bet.

NFL teams went 1-for-31 when trying an onside kick in 2023.  We're actually surprise the payout potential is not higher.

SaintsWire explained why this might be the case:

"Recent NFL rules changes banned a running start for the kicking team as well as how many coverage players teams could line up before the kick, citing safety concerns; the result is that teams now have a 3.2% success rate when trying to recover an onside kick."

The Pittsburgh Steelers' did have a successful attempt in Super Bowl XXX.

The second, and most well-known onside kick in NFL history, was executed by the New Orleans Saints in Super Bowl XLIV.

More Great Super Bowl Prop Options

 Longest Completion - Patrick Mahomes

Over(35.5)

-115

Under(35.5)

-115

Longest Completion - Brock Purdy

Over(37.5)

-115

Under(37.5)

-115

Longest Reception - Brandon Aiyuk

Over(25.5)

-115

Under(25.5)

-115

Longest Reception - Deebo Samuel

Over(21.5)

-115

Under(21.5)

-115

Longest Reception - Rashee Rice

Over(21.5)

-115

Under(21.5)

-115

Longest Reception - George Kittle

Over(20.5)

-127

Under(20.5)

-106

Longest Reception - Travis Kelce

Over(20.5)

-115

Under(20.5)

-115

Longest Reception - Jauan Jennings

Over(12.5)

-115

Under(12.5)

-115

Longest Reception - Isiah Pacheco

Over(9.5)

-115

Under(9.5)

-115

Longest Reception - Christian McCaffrey

Over(14.5)

-115

Under(14.5)

-115

Longest Rush - Brock Purdy

Over(8.5)

-115

Under(8.5)

-115

Kicking Points - Harrison Butker

Over(7.5)

+109

Under(7.5)

-148

Kicking Points - Jake Moody

Over(6.5)

-148

Under(6.5)

+109

Shortest Touchdown Scored

Over(1.5)

+120

Under(1.5)

-162

Longest Reception - Marquez Valdes-Scantling

Over(13.5)

-126

Under(13.5)

-107

Total Game Sacks

Over(5.5)

+159

Under(5.5)

-213

Brock Purdy Yards on First Completed Pass

Over(10.5)

-108

Under(10.5)

-121

Patrick Mahomes Yards on First Completed Pass

Over(8.5)

+100

Under(8.5)

-130

Jersey Number of First Touchdown Scorer

Over(22.5)

-114

Under(22.5)

-114

Jersey Number of Last Touchdown Scorer

Over(22.5)

-114

Under(22.5)

-114

Total Passing Yards (Game)

Over(515.5)

-114

Under(515.5)

-114

Total Touchdown Passes (Game)

Over(3.5)

+120

Under(3.5)

-157

Total Rushing Yards (Game)

Over(240.5)

-114

Under(240.5)

-114

Total Pass Completions (Game)

Over(47.5)

-108

Under(47.5)

-121

Total Pass Attempts (Game)

Over(69.5)

-114

Under(69.5)

-114

Total Rushing Touchdowns (Game)

Over(1.5)

-201

Under(1.5)

+151

Total Rushing Attempts (Game)

Over(50.5)

-114

Under(50.5)

-114

Total Players to Have a Pass Attempts

Over(2.5)

+150

Under(2.5)

-197

Longest Rush - Christian McCaffrey

Over(18.5)

-143

Under(18.5)

+107

1st Half Passing Yards - Brock Purdy

Over(126.5)

-107

Under(126.5)

-126

1st Half Passing Yards - Patrick Mahomes

Over(126.5)

-115

Under(126.5)

-115

Net Yards Gained on 1st Offensive Play

Over(3.5)

-126

Under(3.5)

-107

Longest Rush - Isiah Pacheco

Over(15.5)

-117

Under(15.5)

-114

George Kittle Yards on First Reception

Over(11.5)

-114

Under(11.5)

-114

Christian McCaffrey Yards on First Reception

Over(7.5)

-114

Under(7.5)

-114

Isiah Pacheco Yards on First Reception

Over(5.5)

-130

Under(5.5)

+100

Brandon Aiyuk Yards on First Reception

Over(14.5)

+104

Under(14.5)

-136

Deebo Samuel Yards on First Reception

Over(10.5)

-108

Under(10.5)

-121

Jauan Jennings Yards on First Reception

Over(10.5)

-104

Under(10.5)

-126

Justin Watson Yards on First Reception

Over(14.5)

+119

Under(14.5)

-154

Mecole Hardman Yards on First Reception

Over(7.5)

-114

Under(7.5)

-114

Rashee Rice Yards on First Reception

Over(9.5)

+100

Under(9.5)

-130

Marquez Valdes-Scantling Yards on First Reception

Over(12.5)

-114

Under(12.5)

-114

Richie James Jr. Yards on First Reception

Over(6.5)

-114

Under(6.5)

-114

Brock Purdy Yards on First Rush Attempt

Over(3.5)

+104

Under(3.5)

-136

Christian McCaffrey Yards on First Rush Attempt

Over(3.5)

-126

Under(3.5)

-104

Isiah Pacheco Yards on First Rush Attempt

Over(3.5)

+100

Under(3.5)

-130

Travis Kelce Yards on First Reception

Over(8.5)

-106

Under(8.5)

-122

Patrick Mahomes Yards on First Rush Attempt

Over(7.5)

+100

Under(7.5)

-130

Total Punts

Over(7.5)

+109

Under(7.5)

-143

KC Chiefs Total Sacks against Brock Purdy

Over(2.5)

-115

Under(2.5)

-115

SF 49ers Total Sacks against Patrick Mahomes

Over(2.5)

+150

Under(2.5)

-205

Longest Rush - Patrick Mahomes

Over(13.5)

-115

Under(13.5)

-115

Longest Field Goal Made

Over(48.5)

-115

Under(48.5)

-115

Any QB to throw for 300+ yards

+100

Any player to have 150+ rushing yards

+650

Any QB to throw for 350+ yards

+350

Any player to have 125+ receiving yards

+200

Any player to have 100+ rushing yards

-134

Any player to have 150+ receiving yards

+500

Any Player to Break Super Bowl Pass TD Record (Over 6.5)

+8000

Any Player to Break the Super Bowl Rush Yards Record (Over 204.5)

+3500

Any Player to Break Super Bowl Rec Yards Record (Over 215.5)

+2500

Any Player to Break Super Bowl Pass Yards Record (Over 505.5)

+8000

Any Kicker to Make a 60+ Yard FG

+900

Opening Kickoff Returned for a Touchdown

+8000

First Play from Scrimmage to Result in a TD

+2800

Successful Onside Kick

+1500

Place Your Super Bowl Props Here

- Ean Lamb, Gambling911.com