Bookie Tied to Hockey Player Thomas Vanek Lawyer: ‘NHL Should Investigate Itself’

Submitted by Jagajeet Chiba on

Written by :

Jagajeet Chiba

Published on :

The lawyer for a long time Rochester, New York area bookie, Paul Borrelli, tells local media the National Hockey League (NHL) may want to investigate itself in light of one player’s ties to his client. 

Borrelli will plead guilty April 16 on two criminal counts, according to the Democrat & Chronicle.  He ran his sports betting ring from The Marina Restaurant and Bar in the town of Charlotte, New York. 

Among the bookie’s clients, Thomas Vanek, a former Buffalo Sabre who regularly wagered with the gambling operation.  The NHL star also reportedly cooperated with law enforcement to take Borrelli down.

"I'm shocked that the NHL has not commenced an investigation into whether NHL or AHL players gambled on hockey," Borrelli’s attorney, Vincent Merante, said Tuesday.

Two other individuals have already pleaded guilty to extorting Vanek.  One, Mark Ruff, is facing a sentence of nine years.  Borrelli has not been charged in connection with the extortion plot.

"The NHL players who are supposed to be role models should be embarrassed," Merante said, adding that the National Hockey League should conduct an investigation similar to that which resulted in Pete Rose being exiled from Major League Baseball.

Vanek, for his part, has insisted he never wagered on NHL games.

- Jagajeet Chiba, Gambling911.com

Related Content

Nathan MacKinnon

2026 Conn Smythe Odds for 46 Players: Nathan MacKinnon Pays Out $600 as Favorite

Nikita Kucherov (TB) would pay out $900 for every $100 bet, Cale Makar (COL) pays $1000.
Colorado Avalanche

NHL First Round Series Lines Plus Updated Cup and Conference Odds 2026

The oddsmakers at BetOnline.ag have opened lines for the aforementioned five series.
Maple Leafs hockey team

Toronto Maple Leafs Next GM Betting Odds

The trees have been empty this year in Toronto as the Maple Leafs have fallen on hard times.
Ottawa Senators

NHL Bubble Team Odds to Make the 2026 Playoffs

BetOnline.ag has updated NHL playoff odds for the nine teams not locked into the lottery or the playoffs . You can find the odds and percentages below.